Fractional CMO Marketing + Technology Software development Cybersecurity AI automation Pricing About Results Portfolio Apps Insights Book a Free Strategy Call →
Founder questions · Cybersecurity

What should a small business fix first after a phishing scare?

Quick answer

Fix the account that was touched first: change its password from a different device, sign it out everywhere, turn on two-factor sign-in and check its mail rules and recent sign-ins. If money, bank details or a payment request were involved, call your bank before you do anything else. Then close the gaps that let the email work, starting with two-factor sign-in on every account and a rule that nobody changes payment details without a phone call.

The call usually goes like this. Someone on the team opened an email that looked like an invoice, a shared document or a message from the boss. They clicked, maybe typed a password, and then something felt wrong. Now the owner wants to know two things: did we just lose something, and what do we fix so this does not happen again. Those are separate jobs, and the first one has a clock on it.

First, work out what actually happened

A phishing scare is one of four situations, and each needs a different response. Ask the person who clicked to walk you through it step by step, without blame, because the details decide everything.

The first hour

  1. If money is involved, call your bank now. Ask for the fraud department, give them the transfer details and ask them to try to recall it. Then file a report with the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center at ic3.gov, which banks often ask for.
  2. Secure the account. From a different, clean device, change the password, sign the account out of every session and turn on two-factor sign-in if it was not already on.
  3. Check what the attacker may have set up. Look in the mailbox settings for forwarding rules or filters that move or delete mail. Attackers add these so they can keep reading your email after you change the password. Check the account's recent sign-in activity for locations or devices you do not recognize.
  4. Check the same password elsewhere. If that password was reused on the bank portal, the payroll system or anything else, change those too.
  5. Warn the team. A short message saying a fake email went around and nobody should act on payment requests by email today. Phishing often comes in waves.

The first day

Once the immediate damage is contained, write down a simple timeline: when the email arrived, who clicked, what was entered, and every change you made since. If you have cyber insurance, call the insurer today. Many policies have a hotline and rules about which firms you can use, and acting first and calling later can cause problems with a claim. If the account held client files or personal data, talk to your attorney about whether you have to notify anyone before you send any message to clients.

Then look at the email itself. If it looked like it came from your own company or a vendor you pay, that tells you where the gap is.

What to fix in the next 30 days

The scare is useful because everyone is paying attention. Use the next month to close the gaps that let it work. In order of how much they protect you:

  1. Week 1, two-factor sign-in everywhere. Email first, then banking, payroll, file storage, the domain registrar and any admin account. With it on, a stolen password alone is no longer enough to get in.
  2. Week 1, a payment rule. Nobody changes a vendor's bank details or sends an urgent transfer based on an email alone. They call the person back on a number already on file. Write it down and tell your bookkeeper and your vendors.
  3. Week 2, remove old access. List every account the company uses and who can sign into it. Remove former employees, old contractors and shared logins nobody owns.
  4. Week 3, protect your email domain. Ask whoever manages your domain to set up the email records that let receiving servers reject mail pretending to be from you. These are called SPF, DKIM and DMARC. If nobody knows what those are, that is your answer about who is managing it.
  5. Week 4, test your backups and run a short session with the team. Restore one real file from backup to prove it works. Then spend 20 minutes showing the team the actual email that fooled someone, and what to check next time.

What it costs to fix

Most of the 30-day list costs time, not money. Two-factor sign-in is built into the email and banking tools you already pay for. The payment rule costs nothing. The real cost is the hours, and knowing what to look for.

If you want someone to do it for you, the price follows how many accounts, domains and systems are in scope. At MarkCMO, ongoing hardening and monitoring for most owner-led firms starts with a one-time foundation fee of $4,500 to $15,000, which covers the first month, then $3,000 to $9,000 a month, month to month. The full breakdown, and what changes the number, is on the cybersecurity cost page, and the work itself is described on the cybersecurity page. I run every account myself and target first results within 30 days.

When to get help

Bring in outside help if a password was typed into the fake page, a file ran, money moved, or you cannot say for sure what was touched. Reading sign-in logs and spotting a hidden forwarding rule is not hard, but it is easy to miss if you have never done it. Get help too if the scare showed that nobody really owns security at your company. If you are deciding who that should be, my answer on whether you need a head of IT or a managed IT provider covers the options, and the in-house vs outsourced cybersecurity comparison covers who should be accountable. And if the scare came from a fake invoice that looked like it was from your own brand, that is also a marketing problem: your domain and your reputation are assets, which is part of why I work across marketing leadership and technology.

Frequently asked questions

Someone clicked the link but did not type anything. Are we fine?

Probably, but check rather than assume. Ask exactly what happened after the click: did a page ask for a password, did a file download, did anything install or open. If a sign-in page appeared and nothing was typed, change that person's email password anyway and confirm two-factor sign-in is on. If a file downloaded or opened, take the computer off the network and have someone qualified look at it before it goes back into use.

Do we have to tell our clients about a phishing incident?

It depends on what the attacker reached. If an account that holds client data, such as email with attachments, a file share or a CRM, was opened by someone else, you may have legal or contract duties to notify. The rules vary by state, industry and the contracts you signed. Call your cyber insurer and your attorney before you write to clients, and keep a written timeline of what happened and what you changed.

Is phishing training enough to stop this from happening again?

No. Training helps people slow down, and it is worth a short session after a scare while everyone is paying attention. But a well made fake email will eventually fool someone. The fixes that hold up are the ones that work even when a person clicks: two-factor sign-in on every account, removing old access, locking down who can approve payments, and setting up your email domain so others cannot easily send mail that looks like it came from you.

Should we hire a security company after a phishing scare?

Hire help if a password was entered, a file ran, money moved, or nobody can say for sure what the attacker touched. You need someone who can read the sign-in logs and check for forwarding rules or new devices. If the scare was a near miss, you can do the first fixes yourself with the checklist on this page, then bring in an outside assessment to find the gaps you would not think to look for.

Strategy and the team to execute it

Not just a plan, the tiers to deliver it

MarkCMO provides the strategy and the roadmap, and then delivers it across three tiers, so you get direction and execution from one team instead of handing a deck to someone else to build.

Leadership

Fractional CMO and COO leadership: strategy, positioning, go-to-market, and the roadmap that sets the direction.

Management

Running the function day to day: managing teams, vendors, budgets, and the operating cadence that keeps the plan on track.

Execution

Hands-on delivery: marketing execution, software development, tech-stack build and integration, plus finance and operations support, everything a business needs to scale.

From tech to marketing to finance, strategy through execution, MarkCMO can lead it, manage it, and build it.

Mark Gabrielli seated on a panel speaking into a mic

Talk it through with the fractional CMO who runs it.

See if Mark has availability for a call

Free. 30 minutes. With Mark, not a salesperson.

Not sure what the phishing email reached?

Book a free 30-minute call; you leave with the one thing costing you the most pipeline, and a first list of the security gaps to close this month.

Book a free 30-minute call →

Related