Most companies under about 100 employees do not need a full-time head of IT yet. A good managed IT provider can run the help desk, devices, network and backups, and a part-time technology leader can own the decisions the provider should not make for you. You need an in-house head of IT when technology choices are shaping the business every week and someone has to own them full time, not when tickets are slow.
This question usually shows up after a bad month. A laptop gets stolen and nobody knows what was on it. A big customer sends a security questionnaire and no one can fill it in. The sales team buys a new tool that does not connect to anything. The owner ends up as the IT department by default, and the obvious fix seems to be hiring a head of IT. Sometimes that is right. More often the company has a different problem, and a full-time hire is an expensive way to solve it.
Keeping things running. Password resets, new laptops, printers, Wi-Fi, software updates, backups, monitoring and fixing whatever breaks. This is operational work. It is steady, it is measurable and a managed IT provider is built to do it well at a predictable monthly cost.
Deciding what to run and why. Which systems the company runs on, how they connect, what gets bought and retired, who can see which data, and what the plan is when the company doubles. This is leadership work. A provider can advise on it, but a provider should not be the one deciding, because it is also the one selling you the services.
Most companies that think they need a head of IT actually have the first job handled reasonably well and the second job owned by nobody.
Look at the last three months of IT complaints and sort them into two piles.
If most complaints are about speed and quality of support, such as tickets sitting for days, the same problem returning, or new hires waiting a week for a laptop, the issue is the provider or the contract. Fix that first. Ask for response time commitments in writing and a monthly report. If they cannot meet them, change providers. A head of IT will not make a weak provider faster.
If most complaints are about decisions, such as nobody knowing which system is the source of truth, duplicate tools across teams, a customer security review you could not answer, or a system migration that keeps slipping, the issue is leadership. That is the gap a head of IT, or a part-time technology leader, fills.
If it is both, start with leadership. A good technology leader will diagnose the provider problem within a few weeks and either fix the relationship or replace it.
A full-time hire starts to make sense when technology is a large part of how the business delivers its product, when you have enough internal users and systems that someone must manage vendors and projects every single day, or when regulation in your industry requires a named person who owns it. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics groups this role under computer and information systems managers and reports median pay well above $150,000 a year, before benefits and recruiting costs. That is worth paying when the work fills the week. It is not worth paying to supervise a help desk.
Week one: list every system the company pays for, who owns it, what it costs a month and what it connects to. Most companies find tools nobody uses and data living in three places.
Week two: ask your managed IT provider for its last three monthly reports. Check ticket resolution times, devices behind on updates, backup success and whether anyone has tested a restore. If there are no reports, ask why.
Week three: write down the five technology decisions that are stuck. Typical examples: replacing an aging system, consolidating duplicate tools, answering customer security questions, setting rules for who gets access to what, and planning for the next office or the next 50 hires.
Week four: decide who owns those decisions. If the list is short and the provider is solid, a few hours a month of senior oversight may be enough. If the list is long and keeps growing, you need a leader, and you can test the role part time before committing to a salary.
The cheapest fix is often a better contract with the provider you already have: clear response times, a monthly report and a quarterly review. The middle option is a part-time technology leader working alongside the provider, which costs a fraction of a full-time executive. The ranges for that are on the fractional CTO cost page. A full-time head of IT is the most expensive option and should be the last one you reach for, not the first.
I work with growth companies on marketing and the technology underneath it, including managed IT and cybersecurity. I have spent 15 years leading marketing and operations, the work is month to month with no long contract, and I run every account myself. Technology problems often turn out to be marketing problems in disguise, such as a CRM nobody trusts, which is why I look at both. If the bigger gap is marketing leadership, the fractional CMO page explains how that works, and my answer on whether you need revenue operations or a marketing leader first covers the systems side of growth.
Get help when the owner is still the person everyone asks about technology, when a customer or insurer asks a security question nobody can answer, or when you are about to sign a large software contract without anyone checking how it fits with what you already run. If support is simply slow and everything else is fine, fix the provider contract first and save the money.
A managed IT provider runs the day to day: help desk tickets, laptops and phones, the network, patching, backups and monitoring, usually for a flat monthly fee. A head of IT owns decisions: which systems the company runs on, what gets bought, how data is protected, which vendors stay and how technology supports the plan for the next two years. A provider executes. A head of IT decides and holds the provider to account.
Usually when three things happen together. You run several business systems that must work with each other, such as a CRM, accounting, a customer portal and data reporting. Customers or partners start asking detailed questions about how you protect their data. And leaders are making technology purchases on their own because nobody owns the roadmap. At that point you need someone above the provider, though often part time first.
Yes, and that is often the most cost effective setup for a growing company. The provider keeps running support and infrastructure. The part-time leader sets priorities, reviews the provider's reports, approves purchases, plans system changes and answers the hard questions from customers, insurers and auditors. The provider gets one clear owner to work with instead of five managers sending requests.
Ask for a monthly report and read it. It should show tickets opened and closed, average time to resolve, devices out of date on patches, backup success rate and the results of at least one restore test. If the provider cannot produce those numbers, or if the same problems keep coming back each month, the issue is not more headcount. It is ownership and accountability, and that is what a technology leader fixes.
MarkCMO provides the strategy and the roadmap, and then delivers it across three tiers, so you get direction and execution from one team instead of handing a deck to someone else to build.
Fractional CMO and COO leadership: strategy, positioning, go-to-market, and the roadmap that sets the direction.
Running the function day to day: managing teams, vendors, budgets, and the operating cadence that keeps the plan on track.
Hands-on delivery: marketing execution, software development, tech-stack build and integration, plus finance and operations support, everything a business needs to scale.
From tech to marketing to finance, strategy through execution, MarkCMO can lead it, manage it, and build it.
Book a free 30-minute call; you leave with the one thing costing you the most pipeline, and a straight answer on whether your technology needs a leader or just a better contract.
Book a free 30-minute call →