Table of Contents

The Positioning Playbook: From Generic to Iconic in a Sea of Sameness

the positioning playbook from generic to iconic in a sea of sameness

Most brands don’t have a positioning problem—they have a courage problem. In a world where everyone is zigging with the same tired messaging, the only way to stand out is to zag with intent. This isn’t about slapping a new tagline on your homepage or running a “rebrand” that’s just a new font and a mood board. It’s about building a strategic spine that defines who you are, who you’re for, and why you matter. Welcome to the Positioning Playbook: your guide to going from generic to iconic in a sea of sameness. If you’re ready to stop playing it safe and start playing to win, keep reading.

Why Most Positioning Sucks (And What to Do About It)

Let’s rip the Band-Aid off: most brand positioning is a beige buffet of buzzwords, built by committee, and designed to offend no one—which means it excites no one. If your positioning could be swapped with your competitor’s and no one would notice, congratulations: you’ve successfully become forgettable.

Here’s why that happens:

Fear of alienation: Brands try to appeal to everyone and end up resonating with no one.
Over-reliance on category norms: “We’re the Uber of X” is not a strategy—it’s a cry for help.
Too much internal input: When your positioning is a Frankenstein of stakeholder opinions, it dies on the operating table.

Iconic positioning doesn’t come from consensus. It comes from conviction.

The Positioning Playbook: 5 Moves to Go from Generic to Iconic

Let’s get tactical. Here’s the Positioning Playbook—five strategic moves to help you break out of the sea of sameness and build a brand that actually means something.

1. Pick a Fight (Yes, Really)

Iconic brands stand for something because they stand against something. Patagonia fights fast fashion. Liquid Death fights plastic pollution. What are you fighting?

Identify the enemy: What’s broken in your industry?
Draw a line in the sand: What will you never do that others do?
Make it public: Your positioning should be a manifesto, not a mission statement.

Picking a fight doesn’t mean being negative—it means being clear. Clarity is magnetic. Vagueness is invisible.

2. Own a Specific Problem (Not a Category)

Categories are crowded. Problems are personal. Instead of saying “we’re a CRM,” say “we help sales teams stop losing deals in the follow-up.”

Here’s how to reframe:

Talk like your customer talks. No one says, “I need a scalable SaaS solution.” They say, “I’m drowning in spreadsheets.”
Focus on the pain, not the product. Pain is what gets attention. Relief is what gets conversion.
Be uncomfortably specific. If it feels too narrow, you’re probably getting close.

3. Create a Category of One

Forget category leadership. Be the only one doing what you do, the way you do it. That’s how you go from generic to iconic.

To do this:

Invent new language. Don’t call it a dashboard—call it a Command Center.
Define your own metrics. Don’t optimize for “engagement.” Optimize for “aha moments.”
Package your process. Give your methodology a name. Make it proprietary. Make it yours.

When you create your own game, you don’t have to compete. You just have to show up.

4. Be Unmistakably You

Most brands sound like they were written by a committee of AI interns. Iconic brands sound like a person with a pulse and a point of view.

To build a voice that cuts through:

Write like you talk. If you wouldn’t say it at a dinner party, don’t put it on your homepage.
Use contrast. Humor + insight. Sass + substance. That’s the cocktail.
Kill the clichés. If you see “empower,” “synergy,” or “solutions,” set it on fire.

Your voice is your vibe. Make it unmistakable.

5. Make the Customer the Hero (But You’re the Guide)

Donald Miller didn’t invent this idea, but he did popularize it—and he’s right. Your customer is Luke Skywalker. You’re Yoda. Stop trying to be the hero. Be the one who helps them win.

That means:

Position your product as the key to their transformation.
Show them what success looks like with you—and what failure looks like without you.
Use testimonials, case studies, and proof to show the journey, not just the destination.

When your customer sees themselves in your story, they’ll want to be part of it.

Truth Bomb

If your positioning doesn’t scare you a little, it’s probably not bold enough to matter.

Case Study: How Gong Went from Sales Tool to Sales Icon

Let’s talk about Gong. They didn’t just build a better sales tool—they built a movement. Their positioning? “Reality-based sales.” They didn’t say “AI-powered call analytics.” They said, “Stop guessing. Start knowing.”

They picked a fight with gut-based selling. They created a category around revenue intelligence. They built a brand voice that’s part coach, part hype man. And they made their customers the heroes—sales teams who finally had the data to win.

The result? Gong didn’t just grow. They became iconic.

Conclusion: Your Move, CMO

Positioning isn’t a tagline. It’s a strategic weapon. It’s how you decide what hill you’re willing to die on—and what story you’re going to tell to win hearts, minds, and market share.

If your brand feels like it’s blending in, it’s time to get uncomfortable. Time to pick a fight. Time to say something that actually matters. Because in a sea

“The Positioning Playbook: From Generic to Iconic in a Sea of Sameness”

Table of Contents